March 04, 2003

Rereading

Cryptonomicon doesn't have any interiors to its women. This is a pity, as Stephenson's satire is most effective and kind when showing flaws from both the inside and the out. It's also a pity because the tragic freedom fighter Glory would have had a really interesting inside story, especially in parallel with the tragic Marine Bobby Shaftoe (silver buckles...); and their descendant Amy is not reliably distinguishable from a Barbie doll with a sneer and a big knife. YT had insides; so did her mother, who was unromantically not just a Mom but a petty government official. Clearly Stephenson can manage it. I hope he didn't take it out to write a saleable airplane book, or at least, that the next one will be saleable even with more perspectives.

Dunnett's Lymond novels are still fun, but the period dialogue now sounds a lot more first-half-of-the-twentieth to me, and less gloriously sixteenth. On the other hand, as I read plenty of the originals after tracking down a Dunnett quote, I am still in her debt. (And 1920-1950 are falling into the past enough to have a quaint charm.)

ISBN: 0-380-97346-4

ISBN: 0-7126-0386-7 So wrote clew in SF&F.

And thus wrote others:
TrackBacks turned off...